Week 10 and Conclusion

Before I begin I’d like to give a basic run down of how to use both PLA and SLA printers

You must have a 3d model to print. You can obtain one from websites such as a thingaverse.com and sketchfab.com, create your own using photogrammetry/laser triangulation, or make one using CAD software.

You must slice your file. There are a number of different slicing softwares. The most important thing to remember is that PLA printer require the slicer to produce gcodes, while the SLA printer requires images. If you’re using the PLA printer, and are using the Repetier interface you can configure the slicing setting within the Repetier interface. For the SLA printer I used creation workshop. After entering the printer’s information you import the model and save it. You then click the icon that looks like a slice of cheese.

If you’re using the PLA printer with the repetier interface you press print and it should begin on its own. If using the SLA you must open Kudo’s 3D priting software which is the interface for the printer. You enter the configuration settings for the resin you’re using, and then you upload one of the pictures from the folder that contains the sliced model. You press print and the software should display each layer according to your setting.

Week 10

Week 10 ended with a bit of frustration. Eric presented me with an upgrade kit for the Titan. This biggest feature was the raspberry pi that controlled the print. Because of the school’s firewall, and the inability to enter the Pi it was a bit of struggle actually setting up the upgrade. The pi couldn’t be used without connecting it to my laptop to share internet. From there I would assign it an IP address and use that to enter Kudo 3D’s verision of octoprint. I was able to print the calibration sample they had uploaded using the printing parameters they had uploaded, but there were no directions on how to actually upload sliced models into the octoprint interface. I slided my models using Slic3r, which produced SVGs. I converted these into .png files and zipped them (the same way the calibration sample seemed to be uploaded). However, the software would not recognize the files. I tried a number of different things but none seemed to work.

Attempts:

  • deleting the first image in the folder so the sliced images start at 1
  • Moving the calibration pngs out of the unzipped folder and putting my models pngs into it and then zipping that folder
  • renaming my models folder to match Kudo’s calibration sample’s name

As the week came to an end I had to focus on my presentation. After not being able to successfully upgrade the printer I had to disconnect it from the pi and connect back to the laptop I had been using for the past 10 weeks. I hope to be able to solve this problem at some point in the future. I emailed Kudo, but they still have not replied.

Conclusion

The 10 weeks had its up and downs. Some weeks flew by and others went really slow. I was really happy with the amount of information I learned about 3D printing. However there is still a lot to learn. 3D printing is a technology that is just becoming accessible. I hope that I can put my experiences and knowledge to use in the future, whether its expanding what I’ve learned, or delving into another branch of 3D printing. I’ve never really had to opportunity to venture into a project of my own before and I think I learned a lot about myself and my own workflow. I think one of the most important things when it comes to these types of project is being passionate about what you’re doing. Its very easy to lose motivation when things don’t work smoothly, but as long as you know what you want, and what you hope to gain then it’s even easier to stay focused. I’d like to thank Istvan Urcuyo one of the directors of the STEMscholar program for suggesting that I apply to the program in the first place, and Eric for making it possible. Next summer is still a while away, but I hope that I can return with new knowledge acquired throughout the year to apply into, and further the work I did this summer. What I enjoyed most about the summer was how I was able to work in conjunction with my peers throughout the week, and how our projects were in a way interconnected. I look forward to applying my knowledge throughout the year helping professors who might find my works useful in the classroom.

DTSF Week 9- Jonathan

Week 9 was a pretty busy week. With the DTSF program coming to an end, I had to start tying my project together.

On Monday I was finally able to upload the cura slicing profile to octoprint for the pla printer, unfortunately the settings were terrible, so I had to immediately cancel the print and change them around. When I tried to upload the fixed settings the interface was once again not letting me do so. I spent hours trying to upload different versions of the slicing profile, and none would upload. I let that be for a while, and went to work on the resin printer, since I just got some new hard vats and two containers of the resin Spot-HT. I set up the print of an Ateles skull and gave the skull and the base a larger distance than I usually do. I also oriented it vertically. I did this to maximize the size of the skull printer, while also increasing the length of the supports for easier removal. When I tried to remove the supports from previous skulls sometimes, because the skull was so close to the base, the supports would bunch up and when removing cause the back of the skull to snap. Here is a picture of the print.

Getting some pretty good detail of the models, however I’m still having the problem of the clumping at he base. I’m hoping because the supports are longer it’ll be easier to remove without cracking the back of the skull.

The following day I was finally able to upload slicing profiles to octoprint for the pla printer. I still haven’t found the right settings for the print that I want, but I’ve made progress. I’ve already gone thru about 11 calibration cube prints, I have to see if maybe there is a default with the actual printer itself. Eventually I’ll print a skull so the quality can be compared.

At some point during the week and upgrade package came in for the Titan 1 printer. One of the key feature was that a raspberry pi would be added to run the printer. It’s supposed to run wirelessly, but because of the school’s network it cannot due so. Therefor I have to connect the ethernet cord to my laptop and share internet with the pi in order to run it. However, once the print is starter there is no need for the pi to remain connected. Another feature is the addition of a shutter which flips over the lens in between layers in order to prevent and unwanted curing. The package also included a new large building plate that consisted of many whole throughout. When reading up online the makers said that this was to reduce the vacuum for that was created in between layers. I have yet to try it out, but I’m curious as to the changes this will bring for the printing parameters, if any at all. Also curious as to whether this will increase printing quality. After printing out their calibration model that was uploaded onto octoprint, I came across the problem of acquiring sliced files for my models. The main website for kudo recommends Slic3r, but That produces SVG files, that octoprint doesn’t take. I also don’t really know how to resize the model and configure them according the building plate size. I think I’ll be able to tie up all these loose ends next week in time for my presentation.

DTSF Week 8- Jonathan

It’s hard to believe we’re already in the last couple of weeks of the fellowship. I’ve kept so busy that it flew by. The majority of week 8 was spent working on models provided by the Smithsonian Museum of Natural History. I still haven’t been able to figure out how to work with the extensionless files in the cheetah folder. I worked with a lemur skull that I actually aligned vertically rather than horizontally in order to increase the size of the print. I was worried that a bigger height might break the print halfway through, but it came out perfect. I also printed a castle provided by faculty and the cranium of a stork. The beak of the stork is incredible long so the model had to be scaled down significantly so that it would fit.

 

 

prints of the lemur skull from above and below. there is significant detail through the model, specifically in the teeth.

print of stork

print of castle.

I ran into a little bit of a problem once my resin was running out. The remainder of the week was spent working with the pla printer. Working with James we were able to set up a raspberry pi with the printer, and use the printer through the octoprint interface. There were some problem James encounter with setting up the pi, and eventually set up the printer through the desktop feature of the pi. The next issue was the slicer. On occasion octoprint would not let me upload a cura profile, and when it finally did the stl files would not be sliced. After hours spent reading forums and watching youtube videos, I admitted defeat for the day and postponed my work with the PLA printer until the following weeks. There are two resin tanks coming in so I’ll be able to print a lot more for the last couple weeks. In addition to working with the smithsonian models I also plan to try out the big building plate again and see if I can print out some larger models. I also have to print out a good model of one of my skulls using the PLA printer so the quality can be compared between the resin and PLA printer.

 

DTSF Week 6/7- Jonathan

Week 6/7

The past two weeks haven’t been the most eventful. The majority of time was spent editing models provided by the Smithsonian Museum of Natural History, which includes primates, and other types of animals. I import the files provided from dropbox into meshmixer, where I add a base and overhang support. The biggest problem until now has been creating these supports. It’ tricky because you want the posts to be thick enough to not break during the print, but also thin enough to be able to remove from the completed print.

Through some research I was able to find a blog about working in CAD software. http://www.extrudable.me/2013/12/28/meshmixer-2-0-best-newcomer-in-a-supporting-role/

I’ve been using meshmixer at a really basic level so being able to become better informed on the software has definitely proven to be beneficial. The settings in meshmixer have been really successful. I think I want to work on reducing the size of the tips at the base to make them posts even easier to remove. I’ve recently obtained material to produce a better setup for my photogrammetry station. I want to work on creating turntables of different sizes to enhance the process with different models. I will post pictures of the actual prints later, but for now here is a screenshot of one of the edited models in meshmixer.

Babyrousa

An issue I came across was that the prints appeared to be elongated. The error was an easy fix by correcting the settings for the build plate in the slicing software, creationworkshop. In the upcoming weeks I hope to move onto using the bigger build plate to produce larger size models, and working on the white resin, which has been unsuccessful for printing so far. I think the issue lies with the pigment settling too fast throughout the print.

DTSF Week 4/5- Jonathan

Week 4

One of the goals of my project is to be able to create 3D triangle meshes from pictures a laser scans of fossils and bones. Most of the week was spent trying to set up the Ciclop HE3D laser scanner. Unfortunately it would not connect with any of the computers I’d use, so I ended up trying photogrammetry to produce the meshes. I had already spent sometime playing with Pix4D, but was using the beta software version for macs, which didn’t include all the features provided for a windows computer. After producing a couple of subpar meshes I decided the scans could wait, since I had yet to find the right printing parameters for the Spot-HT resin. The next couple of days were spent editing the printing parameters set for the 3DABS-Orange resin. I began by printing a calibration sample with the Spot-HT resin using the 3DABS settings. To no surprise I had to stop the print 30 minutes in because the base detached. I had to spend a lot of time researching the different types of resins, and the effects that each printing parameter has on the print. I will post some of the information I found later on. After a couple of youtube videos, and a lot of time spent reading posts in forums I was finally able to print the sample, and it printed even better than the calibration sample I printed with the 3DABS resin. To my surprise the Spot-HT resin only required 4 zones (to be explained later), with a layer from 1 to 1 using an exposure time of 35 seconds, a lift of 8mm, an up speed of 15 mm/min, a down speed of 150, mm/min and a 1 second delay time. The second zone was set from layers 2-6 with an exposure time of 15 seconds, a lift of 8mm an up speed of 20 mm/min, a down speed of 150 mm/min and a delay time of 1 second.  The third zone was set from layers 7-40 with an exposure time of 6 second, a lift of 6mm, an up spped of 25mm/min, a down speed of 150 mm/min, and a delay time of 1 second. The fourth and final zone was set from layers 41-608, an exposure time of 4 second, a lift of 4mm, an up speed of 35mm/min, a down speed of 150mm/min, and a delay time of 1 second.

Here’s my first successful print using the Spot-HT resin. The model is the calibration sample provided by Kudo3D. According to Kudo 3D, the purpose of the calibration sample is to be able to optimize printing parameters for specific resins and models. There are specific detail within the model than can help the person operating the printer decide which settings to fine tune. The most important setting to calibrate is the exposure time. An appropriate exposure time can be decided by examining the rectangular slits in the calibration sample. If the right most rectangle is too narrow then the resin is being overexposed. If the columns in between the openings are too narrow then the resin is being underexposed. Factors the affect these setting include viscosity and the amount/type of pigments in the resin. After successfully printing the calibration sample I went on to try to print the model of the femur I had created a while back (see Week 2 post). I left all the printing parameters the same except for the fourth zone where I had to change the layers to coincide with the amount that the model required. The first couple of tries failed because the base wasn’t attaching properly to the building platform. I went back into Meshmixer and editing the model so that the base was thicker and slight longer and wider than the bone itself. I also adjust the supports so that the tips of attachment, and the posts were wider.

It was greatly satisfying to finally print something related to the overall goal of my project. I felt as if progress was actually being made. Although the texture and detail of the print was pretty poor, it is clear that it is a model of a bone, and there isn’t much deviation from the triangle mesh on my laptop. The vat that I had been using was pretty old and beat up so I decided it was time to replace it and try and new one. I printed another calibration sample to make sure the building platform was zeroed properly, and that I didn’t have to make any adjustments to the printing parameters since it was a hard vat (the one I was using before was soft). After a successful print I decided that I would enlarge the femur model I had and try printing it again next week.

Explanation of printing settings and there effects on a print can be found at https://www.kudo3d.com/how-do-i-set-up-the-printing-parameters/

Week 5

Here is the enlarged femur model print, which was successful on the first try with the new hard vat.

Week 5 was a very busy week. I was constantly setting up prints, and then working on producing new models using the photogrammetry software Pix4D during the 3-5 hour long prints. I brought in my Nikon D5100 in order take much higher quality pictures. I used an 18-55 mm lens, and didn’t really make any adjustment to lighting beside putting the turntable in a room with constant lighting (not affect by outside) and putting the subject against a white background. I set the camera on a stand on left with the platform and rotate the table by 15 degrees for each shot. After a full rotation I lifted the camera and angle down towards the subject. I again took picture at every 15 degrees. I then took another four picture with the camera off the stand from an above, slightly angled position. I sent the pictures over to Ryan who was far more experienced with the Pix4D software then me by this point. He produce a mesh and sent it back over to me.

I removed the turntable and part of the rock, added a based, and made the object solid (the scan produce a hollow trilobite which would’ve created a vacuum when printing and ruined the print). Here is the updated trilobite:

and here is what printed:

The print is a perfect example of why it is so important to have a high quality mesh. A lot of the detail on the trilobite was lost and therefor the model looks more like a blob then an actual fossil. I put the photogrammetry on pause for a while and decided to see the types of prints a good mesh would produce.

Although I don’t have the original version I used when I first tried to print it (the first print failed), there isn’t any significant difference besides a thicker longer base and thicker supports.

Here’s the first print that failed because the model split half way though the print. Notice that it split once the skull was as long as the base causing the split when printing and peeling.

Here is the successful print. It is clear that the changes I made were helpful as the base has a slight bend towards the center at the extremities. The next step is making the supports thinner and easier to detach.

The other part of the week was spent trying to produce quality images to produce an even higher quality mesh. This time around I used a Lowell OMNI light to enhance the lighting on the model without produce shadows. In order to avoid shadows I bounced the light off the ceiling in the room. I also lower the platform the turntable was on by using two trash cans and a cardboard from a box I tore apart. I taped white paper on the walls surrounding the turntable and set the camera at an angle above the subject. Here are two pictures of the setup:

I took 2 sets of pictures at the different angles, both from above the plane of the turntable. I sent the pictures over to Ryan, and he was able to produce a much higher quality mesh.

You can really see the difference when comparing it to the mesh produce by pictures without adjusted lighting.

I plan to edit the model and try to print again next week. Hopefully I can get my hands on some new subjects to produce triangle meshes with.

 

The end of the week was spent trying to use a different resin made by MakerJuice LABS. It’s from the G+ line and uses white pigmentation. I started off again with the 3DABS parameters and the calibration sample actually attached to the building platform. Unfortunately the the quality of the print was terrible. I plan on doing some research and reading some forums and hopefully coming up with a better set of parameters. A white pigmented resin would be nice to use for model as it can be later painted.

DTSF Blog Post Week 2-Jonathan

Hey guys here’s my update on my DTSF project for week 2.

It hasn’t been a too exciting week. Most of the week was spent re-calibrating (too many times) the printer, playing around with the Slic3r settings, printing a bunch of things, playing around with meshmixer, a little playing around with the Ciclop HE3D scanner, and playing around with the Pix4D photogrammetry software.

3D Printer

After spending 3 days to build the thing I was finally able to try and print out a calibration cube, which came out really poorly. After that I spent a lot of time on forums reading up on advice that people had to offer about these low quality 3D printers. It really does take a lot of time to figure out how to work these things. I don’t think 3D printing is at the point yet where the average joe can buy one and use it fresh out of the box. In my opinion the most crucial thing to do when tinkering with these printers is knowing exactly what each setting does. In other words, to know the effects that altering any of them may have on the print, and this takes A LOT of practice and time. I think I’ve finally maxed out on the quality of object I can print with this low quality printer. I was able to printer out a Femur, which didn’t come out to bad. I was also able to steal one of the of the people working the 3D printing camp and have them look at my settings.

With the femur I added a bases and created overhang supports. Unfortunately I tried to break the bone off from the base to see how easily the supports could be removed, so here’s a picture of the model in Meshmixer (software for working with triangle meshes).

 

 

Meshmixer

Meshmixer, created by autodesk, is software I can import stl files into and edit them to whichever way I like. Part of this week was spent playing around with it and figuring out how to use all the tools offered by it. I’ve figured out how to change the orientation of my model, remove triangles (make the models smoother), change the dimensions, add bases, and create overhang supports. I’ve also learned how to import multiple stl files and combine the objects into one. What’s nice about meshmixer is that I can import the ply files that Pix4D gives me, edit them, and then export them as stl files into Repetier-Host (software for 3D printing).

Here’s a picture of some of the models I merged and added overhangs to (unfortunately the actual print was a total failure). They were originally 3 different stl files, one of the base, one of the skull, and one of the fangs. I had resize the fangs and the base to fit the skull and then insert the fangs, and the base into the skull.

 

Pix4D

Throughout the past two weeks I’ve been debating a lot whether I want to use photogrammetry, or some sort of structured light scanner, or maybe even both. The problem with sls scanners is that cheap ones’ accuracy isn’t below 1mm which is the accuracy I require for replicas of bones and skulls, and the ones that have a below 1mm accuracy are wayyyyyy too expensive. Photogrammetry seems to be the “cheap” fix. Cheap is in quotations because the software is till pretty expensive. However, it works out great because Ryan can also use this software for his drone mapping and statue scanning. I used my iPhone to take a bunch of pictures of a glue stick and a coffee cup. The more pictures you take at the appropriate angles produces a better scan. I had to awkwardly wrap my behind the glue stick to take pictures of the back which is why the front looks better than the back. I’m going home this weekend so I’m going to grab my Nikon and hopefully be able to produce higher quality scans.

Here’s a picture of the glue stick scan in the Pix4D software.

The green dots are the pictures used to create the triangle mesh. They’re at the angle/distance where the software calculates the picture was taken from. Im thinking about using the rotating plate on the Ciclop HE3D laser scanner to take picture at constant distances/angles of my subjects.

 

Ciclop HE3D

The ciclop scanner has actually been a pain to work with. Sometimes it connects with my computer through the Horus software, but most of the time it doesn’t. The setup wizard says that the wrong firmware is uploaded, and that I have the wrong AVR board selected but regardless of the one that I choose (arduino or mega) it still doesn’t work! The one time I got it two work the two lasers were misaligned and produced a double image. If I’m able to get it running again I think I’m going to try just using one laser to scan.

Here’s the set up I have for the scanner right now.

 

I’m extremely excited to finally be able to work with the titan resin printer next week. Hopefully I’ll be able to figure out the configuration and calibration a lot faster, and produce way higher quality prints.

 

 

DTSF Blog Post Week 1-Jonathan

Introduction

Hello and welcome to the first of my 10 weekly blog posts. My name is Jonathan Trilleras, my hometown is Plainfield, NJ, I am a rising sophomore majoring in Biochemistry and Molecular Biology on track for the 3-2 year dual degree engineering program for Biomedical Engineering. I’m also a part of the first class of STEMscholars at the school, a program that has provided me with a number of great opportunities.  I’m currently torn between my love for medicine, specifically orthopedics, and my love for physics and math (which is why I’m on track for BME). However, that’s a very big decision to be made at a later time. I just finished up my first year of college and it was everything I wanted and more. On campus I was involved with the Office of Multicultural Engagement in the recruitment of underrepresented minorities. I have actually just been selected along with another peer of mine to be a Coordinator for Multicultural Admission in the fall. I’m very excited for this great opportunity and can’t wait to begin in the fall. I also a apart of the Club Rugby team at school, as I played for an extremely competitive team in high school and decided it was something I wanted to continue in college. The week between the end of finals and the beginning of the DTSF program I completed and externship through Gettysburg College with a Gastroenterologist, and by shadowing was able to see the routine of a GI doctor in the office of a private practice, in a hospital, and in at an endoscopy center. It was a lot of fun, and something I think I benefitted from greatly, as he connected with other’s in the field for more resources. The DTSF program will serve as a little into to what I would potentially be doing as a Biomedical Engineer, and I am excited to dip my toes in the water.

Overall Goals

In a perfect world where everything goes my way and there’s nothing but great work flow by the end of the summer I would love to have a prosthetic who’s movement I can control electrically or through a mechanical system. If I am not able to reach this point I would at least like to be able to scan an object (like a skull or hand) and produce an accurate STL that can then be printed by the Titan resin printer to produce a replica. Reproducibility is key, as I will be working in professors in the future to teach them what I’ve learned.

Week 1

After a quick group meeting Monday morning every was hard at work with their projects. Eric had gotten 3D printers for me to set up and play around with in order to get used to the Repetier software for printing. James Arps, another DTSF, was also building one of Flsun-7 3D printers, so if either of us ever got encountered a problem we kind of worked together to solve it. Building the printer was pretty straightforward although the instructions were basically a bunch of pictures that we had to compare our printer materials to as we went along. After having to switch up a couple things I finally had the printer up and running by Wednesday. I had to instal the Arduino and Repetier-Host software in order to work the printer. However, after installing these two things and connecting my printer, the commands I was sending through Reptier-Host were not going through to the printer. I spent a couple hours playing with the printer setting but nothing seemed to work. Eric had no idea what was wrong either since he was not a mac user. Eventually we thought that we might have to use my Windows laptop, which would’ve been a pain since I’m used to macs. On Thursday Eric eventually remembered that the problem was with the driver. Macs apparently have trouble with the driver that comes with the printer to recognize the USB connection therefor we had to go online and download the appropriate driver for macs at http://kig.re/2014/12/31/how-to-use-arduino-nano-mini-pro-with-CH340G-on-mac-osx-yosemite.html. Finally the printer was responding to my commands! Since then I have been playing around with the printer settings along with the Slic3r settings to get more accurate prints. I’ve been able to print 3 calibration cubes, and 2 batman logos. None are at the level of accuracy I require though. I also began to play around with the Ciclops Laser Triangulation scanner that Eric had, but had a little trouble calibrating it.

Next week I need decide if photogrammetry or laser scanning is going to be used for the creation of STLs for my scans. The two things to take into consideration are cost and accuracy.

Upcoming Weeks

One of the challenges of creating a plan is that there always are unforeseen challenges. It’s also impossible to tell how long something is going to take. Something that I might expect to take me a week might take me two days, and something I might think will take me a day could take me a week. Next week i need to decide on whether I’m going to use photogrammetry software, laser triangulation, or both. Additionally I need to master the basic 3D printer I have, and start playing around with the Titan. For weeks 4-5 I need to become avid with the Titan resin printer, and whatever software I decide to use to produce scans. During week 6 I want to be able to easily replicate common objects. Week 7 I will move onto more bones. Week 8 I plan to move on to creating prosthetics based off the bone scans that I have. Week 9-10 I’ll play around with the functionality of these prosthetics, and how I’m going to control their movement. I also have to compile all my work and create a presentation. As I mentioned in my the Overall Goals section by the end of the summer I at least want to effortlessly be able to replicate bones and skulls, and things of that nature. I am very excited for the weeks to come.